Review of Mr. Miracle by Debbie Macomber

Harry Mills is a guardian angel on a mission: help twenty-four-year-old Addie Folsom get her life back on track—and, if the right moment strikes, help her find love. Posing as a teacher at a local college in Tacoma, Washington, Harry is up to the task, but not even he can predict the surprises that lay in store.

After trying to make it on her own, Addie has returned home to Tacoma for the holidays, but this time she plans to stay for good, enrolling in the local community college to earn her degree. What she doesn’t plan to do is run into Erich Simmons.

Addie and her next-door neighbor, Erich, are like night and day. Growing up, he was popular and outgoing while she was rebellious and headstrong, and he never missed an opportunity to tease her. Now she intends to avoid him entirely, yet when they’re suddenly forced to spend Christmas together, Addie braces for trouble.

Perhaps it’s the spirit of the season or the magic of mistletoe, but Addie and Erich soon find they have more in common than they thought—and that two people who seem so wrong for each other may actually be just right. With a little prompting from a certain angelic teacher, the two are in for a holiday miracle they’ll never forget.

Available on Amazon

Hmmm…. I’ve seen lots of lovely reviews of Debbie Macomber books and I was really excited to try this one. Originally I planned to read Merry and Bright but then Bookbub offered me Mr. Miracle for much less so I took that one instead. I’m not sure it was the best decision but I did enjoy the read.

This story reminded me of a Touched by an Angel episode. There was an angel learning the ropes, a more experienced angel guide and a few people in need of divine intervention. Two unhappy people find a way to bring happiness to their lives and let in the Christmas spirit while falling in love. It’s cute, it’s short and it’s about the magic of Christmas. Those are the bits I really enjoyed in this tale.

Yes, it’s a love story but I would have liked some more tension built into the actual falling in Love. What makes them, after all these years, finally agree that they can make each other happy?

What disappointed me in this story is that I wanted more depth to the characters. At the start, they seemed like very complex figures that I’d have enjoyed getting to know better. I felt as though just enough was provided to hook me, but then not enough was done to allow me to delve into and savour how these people change.

Erich is painted as the golden boy from next door. He’s a bit jaded in love because of a past relationship. His previous love is cast as a vixen with no explanation as to why she is so. Also, we don’t get enough insight into his present life or his past. We just see him as anti-Christmas and realise that it’s up to Addie to change this.

My biggest peeve, however, is that there is no explanation given for how poorly he treated Addie in the past. He was pretty much a bully to her. Why? I’m not sure he ever properly apologises for how mean he was. Why the change of heart now?

We get a bit more insight into Addie herself. Her major issue is that she needs to be more self-confident and realize that she can indeed succeed in an academic and then professional setting. The biggest gap in her story is the years she spent away from home. Bits and pieces are referred to several times but no satisfactory backstory is explored.

The epilogue does a good job in explaining how things will play out to suit the main characters and even some of the secondary ones. By way of resolutions, therefore, this story offers good ones.

I also enjoyed the references to the Charles Dickens Christmas Classic, A Christmas Carol. It’s the book the class studies and I learnt a new thing or two about Mr. Dickens.

Overall I give this book 3.5/5 miraculous shots.


35 thoughts on “Review of Mr. Miracle by Debbie Macomber

Add yours

  1. Ha ha!!! I just watched this Hallmark movie. 😂😂 It had the guy from Northern Exposure as the angel… I love him. But, I agree with your take on it. The movie was the same way (… But, I don’t usually expect much depth in Hallmark! 😅) I didn’t understand how the angel was portrayed… In the movie he was almost autistic. Is he that way in the book? They just describe him as a “little odd”, but the mannerisms of the character defintitely put him on the spectrum. I didn’t know if that was just bad acting, or if it was supposed to be this way?

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Oh my goodness I am cracking up over this one. He’s not supposed to be on the spectrum. He’s just new at ‘earth work’ and is learning the ropes still and making mistakes as he goes along! 😂😂
      Yeah… for a Hallmark movie it would be just fine. I was expecting something a little deeper in the book. Maybe I’ve been spoiled by some of my other reads this season 😊🎄🌲🎊

      Liked by 2 people

      1. My Christmas reads haven’t been too stellar so far… But, I’ve only had time for TWO! 😲 It’s been overwhelmingly crazy… But, started at about 10pm tonight I have TWO WHOLE DAYS OFF!!! Oh…. I really hope I get some reading done! 😅 (… Or possibly some Christmas shopping?? Eh. No.)

        Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a website or blog at

Up ↑

lilian's blog

lifestyle and humanitarian stories? is that what you looking for? you are in the right place

Author Julie Seedorf

Author, Columnist, Dreamer

Let's talk Pop Culture!

A forum for discussing all things nerdy.


Book Blog

the bubbles inside my head

My bibliophilic journey and more.


Book blog and book love

Laurie Woodward

An Author Promoting Peace Creatively

The Reading Chemist

Out of the lab & into the books!

b u g ∙ b u g


Leave Me Alone I Am Reading and Reviewing

Look Below the Keys for Books Reviewed by a Readaholic

Books and Bindings

Books, reads, writings, reviews, nonsense, silliness, and everything in between.

Just Simply Me...

This gal's thoughts on all things entertainment mixed with the simple things in life.

Creating Worlds with Words

Writers endeavor to create a world that you lose yourself in.


For Booklovers.

Ambivert words


Combing Through the Pages

of Books, Family, Fostering, and Faith

Bookish Brownie

My Bookish Experiences


Book Reviews and More

%d bloggers like this: